O.S No.1232/2019

Case between Catholic Truth Charitable Society et al vs Ernakulam Angamaly Archdiocese Bishop House et al regarding representative suit rejection

Court

COURT OF THE PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF, ERNAKULAM

Judge

Sri. Rohit Nandakumar

Order Date

2024-11-29

Duration

Case Closed

Judgement document from eCourt website

Save Case Find Similar Cases

Case Summary

The case involves Catholic Truth Charitable Society and its representatives as plaintiffs against the Ernakulam Angamaly Archdiocese Bishop House and other defendants. The court found that the plaintiffs had no individual right or title to the suit property and rejected the case.

Judgment Outcome

Defendant Won

Interim Order

The court ruled that the plaintiffs lack the necessary standing to maintain the suit as they do not have individual rights regarding the property in question. Therefore, the case was rejected.

Judgment Favored

Defendant

Relief Granted

Case Type

Civil Suit

Final Judgment

The court ruled that the plaintiffs lack the necessary standing to maintain the suit as they do not have individual rights regarding the property in question. Therefore, the case was rejected.

Key Reasoning:
The court determined that the plaintiffs had no individual rights or title to maintain the suit.

Why Defendant Won:
The court determined that the plaintiffs had no individual rights or title to maintain the suit.

Supporting Evidence

The plaintiffs per se has no individual right or title with respect to the suit property to have a locus standi in this case.

Judgment Evidence:

The suit is filed without obtaining a permission under Order 1 Rule 8 and no permission has been obtained till date. Hence suit is not maintainable and is rejected.

Parties Involved

Parties

Party Role: Plaintiff
Party Name: Catholic Truth Charitable Society
Relation: represented by

Party Role: Plaintiff
Party Name: Sebastian Koikkara Kurian
Party Age: 66
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Plaintiff
Party Name: Joshi Varghese
Party Age: 56
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Plaintiff
Party Name: Sebastian Koikkara
Party Age: 66
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Plaintiff
Party Name: Joshi Varghese
Party Age: 56
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Defendant
Party Name: Ernakulam Angamaly Archdiocese Bishop House
Party Age: 69
Relation: represented by

Party Role: Defendant
Party Name: Archbishop Mar Antony Kariyil CMI
Party Age: 69
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Defendant
Party Name: Cardinal Mar George Alancheri
Party Age: 74

Party Role: Defendant
Party Name: Fr. Joshi Pudhuva
Party Age: 44
Relation: S/o

Party Role: Defendant
Party Name: Lakshmanan Lakshmi
Party Age: 51
Relation: W/o

Plaintiffs Documents

Defendants Documents

Advocates

Party Role: Plaintiff
Advocate Name: V. Rajendran
Appearance Type: Main Counsel
Law Firm: Perumbavur

Party Role: Plaintiff
Advocate Name: M. Narendrakumar
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Plaintiff
Advocate Name: Rajesh N
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Litto Palathingal
Appearance Type: Main Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: K.B Mohanan
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Baby M.M
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Jijo Paul Kalloorkkaran
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Saju N. A
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Lekha G
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Uma G. Krishnan
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Flony P. J
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Aleesha M. P
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Party Role: Defendant
Advocate Name: Anupama Radhakrishnan
Appearance Type: Assisting Counsel

Documents & Evidence

Case Classification